Extremely High Horizon Refraction
[ version française du site EH2R ici ]


Description: Refraction of sun light due to cold dense polar air under warmer thermal layers causes an increase in brightness almost unknown within present physics literature. Global Warming may be seen by studying simple satellite picture archives. Low on the horizon polar sunsets have sun disks compressed into a line. Thermal Inversions cause equally an increase in brightness during twilight.

This page contains a vast database pertaining to temperate and polar sunsets. It also holds many differential refraction pictures, at multiple Zenith Angles. Recently conceived twilight brightness theory with respect to the Y-V Ulluq Q effects are presented. Extraordinary Moon shots show simple refraction. The data is there for you to study, the thoughts are progressive from February 2001 till today, they change according to knowledge acquired from this page and from other pages as referred to below. The data presented is quite accurate, calculations if any can be verified, while past thought mistakes are left untouched, in order to leave the examiner review a fascinating journey in science. Major paradigm shifts will be explained on each individual pages, they will be recognizable by the date they are written.

WD, December 2004


Atmospheric Refraction is very misunderstood or rather under-studied, it has enormous potential to solve apparently complex problems, like the true temperature of the troposphere. A landmark paper:

SUNSET SCIENCE. IV. Low-altitude refraction. By Andrew T. Young, Departnment of Astronomy, San Diego State University, Astronomical Journal, 127:3622-3637, 2004 June.

Proves without much doubt that Astronomical refraction is caused in the Troposphere. This certain fact can help ascertain key measurements, as used on this webpage, helping to calculate the temperature of the lower troposphere, without MSU doubts, such as radiometer microwave satellite readings which fail to distinguish the Stratosphere from the Troposphere.

Another important paper has shown the sun seen by explorers in 1597 at -5.7 degrees below the horizon. This record still holds to this date:

S. Y. van der Werf, G. P. Können, W. H. Lehn, F. Steenhuisen, and W. Davidson, "Gerrit de Veer's True and Perfect Description of the Novaya Zemlya Effect, 24 -27 January 1597 ," Appl. Opt. 42, 379-389 (2003)

Click here for Link

WD April 27, 2007

old description




EH2R News 2009

Early El-Nino impacts clouds April's temperature projection

Courtesy NASA GISS


Now that its almost a certainty. El-Nino will affect weather world wide, of which using 1997-1998 as an example, world wide temperature averages will go up. This fits with my April projection by accident (no ENSO would have mean lesser clouds and a dead on projection), In North America, a summer El-Nino means a cooling, I am happy to explain this with the Anvil seeding theory. In spring 2009 Arctic, sun disk measurements were "hot" expanded, implying directly, thinner sea ice, but the over all atmosphere is not the same as surface temperatures. If clouds, as they are, reflect most of the sunlight back to space, the surface temperatures will be cooler, Montreal early June sun disk measurements, despite cooler cloudier surface weather, do not show signs of imminent cooling at all. The surface may be cooler, but overall temperature of the entire atmosphere is quite warm.

However since most people live on the surface of the Earth, the clouds throughout Northern North America are so pervasive, as to literally cool the beginning of summer, for the surface dwellers, El-Nino increases over all clouds, whitin summer or winter, For North Americans it will be a variable summer, at times very hot, with cooler cloud driven periods in between, with obviously more rain. EL-Nino will warm things up , but in some parts of the world, you might think this is not so. Europe highly likely will bake, as with this August 1997 map when EL-Nino was in a hot state, most of North America was cooler, but Europe went into a hot spell. Cloud dynamics are such that nucleation seeds likely are useless over Northern Africa's Sahara, while South of America, the Mexican desert is so much smaller.

wd June 9, 2009



CLOSE to the Anvil Seeding theory- intriguing recent articles

There is lesser doubt about tropical cyclones affecting Global Warming, here and here,

The conclusions given resembles to my proposed Anvil seeding theory, the Stratosphere is largely very dry, it would take enormous amounts of moisture to make moisture give permanent clouds there. But Overshooting thunderclouds do leave cloud seeds, once cumulo nimbus anvils dissipate. There is another aspect, the stratosphere is largely getting cooler as global warming progresses. This is expected by models, but more heat from Cyclone thunderstorm overshooting may be created indirectly, by more clouds in the Arctic winter. I suggest a connection in thunderstorm stratospheric overshooting leaving an invisible trail of cloud seeding aerosols. The warming mechanism may be cloud seed redistribution particularly in the Arctic.

WD June 5, 2009



ANVIL seeding in full bloom in the Arctic?

-ENSO related causations from afar

As you read further below, and especially with 2008 news, Refraction temperature projections hit a snag in 2008. Whereas I was able to predict world temperature trends easily for years, since 2003, until about beginning of 2008. Then there was a major cloud free event, which caused a return to a cold winter. As the clouds were scarce, March ,April and May 2008 surface temperatures shot upwards significantly during spring. I observed a great number of sun disk observations, then, end of May onwards the Arctic clouded over, preventing a major Arctic Ocean melt similar to 2007. As it turns out, 2007 had a mild end of winter, tempered by EL-Nino, which infers a cloudy winter over the Arctic, however, there was a great melt, which occurred during summer of 2007 coinciding with an abrupt La-Nina starting in March 07. It was a perfect melt scenario, warm winter, cloud free summer, equated a great melt of Ocean ice in the Arctic.

This year, 2009, proves to be the reverse of 2007, La Nina peaked in January, with strong evidence that EL-Nino is about to strike: LINK

The refraction observation season was quite good for sunsets in the High Arctic 09, there were few clouds, from February till March, with gradual increasing cloudiness afterwards, again looking at the linked ENSO chart, the link is clear, La-Nina means a less cloudy Arctic, favorable for colder weather during winter.. This NOAA link attributes the common observations during ENSO periods. Essentially it proposes planetary waves as the immediate cause altering climate during EL-Nino events. However the jet stream position is not only affected by equatorial heat fluctuations. but by Arctic overall heat conditions the 2 conditions in tandem affect temperatures world wide. For instance the warm corridor, along the Can-Am rockies during winter as per link, is caused by the Arctic clouded over, Arctic in origin weather systems descending the corridor start at a warmer level. La Nina in winter reverses this scene, the cloud free Arctic is much colder during winter, the weather systems skimming down the East side of the rockies come from a much colder Arctic, this makes the East side of the rockies cold and dry.

The stratospheric polar vortex plays an important role as well, if it rages strong it keeps clouds seeds in suspension until the vortex collapses.

This vortex usually starts in November and ends in March, not always as such, but one must consider its influence seriously.

Other ENSO events seem to confirm Arctic cloud extent fluctuations, as well as impacts over arctic ocean sea ice extent as well.

Theoretically melt season 09 is going to be not as bad as 08 and 07 because clouds should dominate North of 65 during a stronger El-Nino....

wd May 31, 2009



SUMMER 2009 will be hot....

As already showing in some parts of the world. Despite what the meteorologist says, skeptics about Anthropogenic Global Warming may be puzzled, a prolonged spotless sun must make proponents about Galactic Cosmic Rays baffled, after all should we be swamped with clouds?

The high Arctic winter just past was mild, not so cloudy, not so devoid of clouds. Perhaps reflecting burgeoning ENSO neutral conditions. April 28 in Resolute marks the return of Snow buntings, incredible long distance little migrating birds, their arrival announce spring. A bit early if I am not mistaken. Sea ice is at all time thinness, signaling the disappearance of multi-year ice. It seems the Arctic is in a solid feedback warming spiral. No signs of change to that.

Sun disk vertical diameters were already very expanded as reported below.

Then, beginning of April struck "seasonal" lasting 3 weeks, before all time high temperatures ended the month. But all time high sun expansions never really relented, until mega boosts in size sprung at month end. The link appears to be with DWT's which maintained around 243-245 K range until end of month 250's which coincided with dramatic increases in expansion.

There is no reason to believe a cold summer, despite no sun spots at all.

An apparent contradiction if there was no supplementary man made greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. All time high temperatures everywhere in the Northern Hemisphere are foreseen,the only thing stopping a greater melt down of the arctic ocean ice, an encroaching El-Nino, fostering greater cloud coverage, as with the anvil seeding theory.

WD May 3, 2009



Potential breakthrough in sunset science

-actually defines the sea-lower atmosphere heat exchange interplay

I will delay somewhat my mid-April prognosis, the cold temperature North Pole was exactly about Resolute, this is not unusual, but it rapidly changed end of March trends, by a strong persistent bought of seasonal temperatures! Which requires more study.

However, even in the middle of the cold temperature North Pole, sun disks went expansive, 2009 is #1 in vertical expansion for certain, which is to say, it may be a normal end of spring around Cornwallis Island, but it is not towards the West, over the northwest passage.

Ice thickness is definitely key, and depends on several factors, salinity, sea and air temperatures, all of which affect each other, but the trump card is old ice, which melted a lot during the last few years. Old sea ice is remarkably salt free, so there was a great injection of fresh water over the sea surface from 2005-2007 especially, but now that most of the old ice is gone, summer melting of new ice in 2008 causes an injection of saltier water, which in effect does not freeze as readily. There is also the question of old ice, about its basic physical presence in great extents, affecting greater cooling/conduction of the surrounding newer ice. Vanishing old ice helps thinning the newer ice in its long night wake. This is seen, not only by measuring sea ice thickness, but by sun disk dimensions and sunset tardiness.

2001 was at the end of a prolonged La-Nina, which turns out to be the start of my extensive sunset observation research effort. In 2001 there was 7 sunsets lower than -2 degrees, well below the astronomical horizon. At the end of a La-Nina of 2008-09, there was no sunsets below - 2 degrees. A remarkable change.. Meaning; whatever ENSO gives, ENSO takes back, it is an overall temperature neutral event, but there was, since 2001 great changes in the Arctic, the Polar average temperature rose, along with thinner and the near disappearance of older ice. ENSO warms, then cools everything back, but overall its warmer.

Sunset tardiness is in direct relation to the heat exchanged over the long invisible horizon. Over the Polar sea, if there is thinner ice, sunsets move Southwards. This is seen in fact at every onset and end of the long night in Resolute, over Barrow strait, where in November much thinner ice, makes the sunset disappear earlier, then when there is thicker ice in February, and so my records easily prove that. But lately, a great shift in tardiness over sea ice was observed in March. When sea ice should be at its thickest, as you can read below, there was a great shift Southwards, despite nearly identical sunset geometry in all its phases. The ice is thinner, it gives off more Infra red heat, warming the air immediately above, this makes sunset science a powerful tool in confirming different temperature profiles not so far away from an Upper Air station. There is the question as to whether the models incorporate ice thickness feedbacks, and also whether the present station monitoring grid, is good enough to represent all its missing rather large gaps...

WD April19, 2009



1 K a year warming?


So it seems, March is the turning point , when cold peeks, and warm moves in. Density Weighted temperatures seem to confirm it, where as EROAM is a temperature measurement of the entire atmosphere, calibrated to a standard March 238 Kelvin for the troposphere. DWT, the standard method measure of upper air, also confirms it, even for 2009, since in 2009 there were only 18 days of inter-comparison for the graph. For the entire Month of March 2009, DWT was 239.8 K. March 2009 had a steady cooler period until the very end of the month, when much fewer comparisons were made. The difference in temperatures between DWT and EROAM is a matter of calibration, what matters is that EROAM kept on measuring warmer each year. 1 K a year seems like a big increase, but there is a need to continue and see if this trend continues, until next year.

WD April 4, 2009


Proof of warming since...... 2005

5s03_21_05
9s0321_005828a
Click on either images for larger version

Amazing evidence of recent warming despite almost identical sunsets 4 years apart. To the left
an equinox sunset , -2.60 degrees below the horizon during very warm 2005. To the right, a very similar sunset, a coincidental same day marvel, but it set much higher and much further towards the South. The difference between these two sunsets is not measured, since all the action is played over NW passage ice, and there are no stations there. The lower atmosphere in 2009 has to be warmer than in 2005. By deduction, Northwest passage ice in 2009 must be thinner than in 2005. It looks more and more like an extreme melting extent season is about to start.

WD March 31, 2009



What is the score?

2005 20%, 2006 16%, 2007 12%, 2008 13%, 2009 22%.

200 observations, average or single sun disk maxima comparisons between -1 and 10 degrees.

2009 just exceeded 2005 in sun disk expansion...

This with mainly low sun observations at the coldest period possible, hence the low above horizon sun of winter end 2009 was more expanded vertically than with the sun disk averages of winter/springs in Resolute from the past 8 seasons. This means that it will be a warm spring, for the Arctic and likely more Southwards, ENSO is the trump card, changing prognostications for the wider Northern Hemisphere, however my latest projection for winter seems accurate for the Arctic, not the Northern Hemisphere. In the past, whatever the Arctic trend preceded the rest of the NH, it is not quite "back to normal" yet, but getting there, I must caution that confidence in in this projection is very high for the Arctic ( a near certainty), uncertain for the rest of the NH, until the mid April temperature projection.

WD March26, 2009



A net shift southwards


[9s0321_005828N] Click image for bigger version

Equinox sunsets are known big events here in Resolute, clouds permitting. 2001 and 2005 sunsets were as low as 2.7 degrees below the astronomical horizon. 2009 a paltry 1.86 degrees. Following a pattern more consistent than not of sunsets shifting Southwards, the last below -2 degree sunset was years ago. In this recent case, sunset sequence geometry between 09 and 05 were nearly identical, yet the boost upwards severely diminished. Suggesting thinner ice over the Western NW passage.

WD March 25, 2009



No sign in cooling, LaNina remnants linger, but weather signals are different



January 2009 Latitudinal anomalies courtesy: NASA

Since the last LaNina there has been an apparent greater disparity between Arctic warmer surface air anomalies and Sub-Arctic. The Arctic virtually always leads the way in greater anomalies, since I do most of my refraction readings here, it is always easy to say the the rest of Northern Hemisphere will follow in warmer anomaly gains, but LaNina threw a monkey wrench into my Northern Hemisphere temperature projections. It seems that the last LaNina effects are fading, its cloudier than last year's big blue, I've noted several sunsets which appear to shift left, including much rounder in appearance. Standard DWT's have been remarkably warmer since September 08, on a streak of significant monthly warming compared to 2007 (except for October 2008). All this seems to confirm, the return of parity between Arctic and sub-Arctic anomalies making an Arctic Projection identical to the rest of the Northern Hemisphere. Anvil seeding theory seems potent and correct, there has been a greater Cyclonic presence North of Alaska, splitting the cold temperature North Pole in 2, assuring a milder winter scenario unfolding as expected. Would expect February 2009 data to show strong anomaly warming pretty much everywhere.

WD March 1, 2009



Calling on AIRport wind Safety expert

There is a way, aside from doppler Radar, to see air turbulence. Even if no winds are near the ground you can observe it:


9d0301_184806

But shortly after the winds stopped


9d0301_201729


Any light source, even artificially placed, on purpose for the same study, after a great well established analysis, can reveal winds not felt, neither measured, and this may increase wind shear knowledge and of course airport safety.

WD March 1, 2009



Great brightness in the High Arctic



Great Y-V Ulluq Q effect, following extensive week of deep cooling, warm air moved upwards , illuminating the twilight greatly.


Click photo for larger version


Look to the right of>>> and notice Somerset Island really raised above the ice horizon, mountains especially, as the horizon is raised, so is sunlight. The brightness is directly proportional to inversion lapse rates, which in this case, was off the charts, very strong. It is not technically a mirage, since more light is generated then otherwise would have been.

WD Jan 24, 2009



Splitting of Stratospheric vortex, precursor to a cloudier warmer end of winter?

Link

As seen in the link above, unlike last year, the vortex is splitting in 2, complicated physical dynamics make it so. Last Spring the vortex raged for months, unperturbed, coinciding with an Arctic "big blue" phenomena, which brought severe cold weather from January till March in the High Arctic and well further Southwards. Now the Arctic has been largely warmer than last winter during the same period. Continues to be this way:

Link

If my Anvil seeding theory is correct, there will be no "big Blue" until the vortex reconsolidates, if it does that blue cold skies will return, if not there will be ample clouds everywhere, not just the Arctic, simply warming the Northern Hemisphere.

WD Jan22, 2009



Projection nearly bang on

-November 2008 very warm, Arctic Ocean ice freezing extent significantly slowed.

Here is the track record:



Very warm troposphere mainly in November, caused by extensive cloudiness reflecting heat towards the surface, slowing the freeze up of the Arctic Ocean , with a lag, showing a virtual slow down in in December, causing a warming feedback. Remember 2007 was the warmest year in Northern Hemisphere history, end of 2008 center of the Canadian Archipelago is warmer than 2007. There are no signs of cooling just warming as expected... Stratosphere is cold but not as windy.

Link

Last year winds exceeded 200 knots. Vortex being not so intense means less mixing of particles.

WD Jan1, 2009




For past EH2R news:

The complete news for 2008

The complete news for 2007

The complete news for 2006

The complete news for 2005

Y-V Ulluq Q Phenomena (March 22 2005)

Star colors and waves as seen by ARCTURUS

SUMMER 2004 version 2

SUMMER 2004

Mars EH2R link?

Winter 2004


Summer 2003


 
 
EH2R Introduction
Darkness and Brightness during Twilight - Compare examples of Y-V Ulluq Q

**UPDATED May 14, 2008**
Comparison gallery. And the 3 basic sunset science rules.
A big thermometer? Differential Refraction. UPDATED Feb 16, 2008
Polarization at the POLES. Sounds strange? It isn't!
The real argument Terminator! Showing that greater refraction exists at the poles.
Streaming over the moon
Double Sunset
Old pictographic archives; one with the sun 4 degrees below the horizon.
EH2r and how to prove Global Warming without waiting for the flood
The last "line" sunset of the season
Sunrise, effects caused by a warmer atmosphere.
One Polar Sunset Sequence
The latest EH2R data files ** UPDATED MARCH 1, 2008 **
Homage to Gerrit de Veer, novaya zemlya effect. Gerrit de Veer proven! Please look at reference: http://aolp.osa.org/abstract.cfm?id=71002

Congratulations to Siebren Y. van der Werf and colleagues on this accomplishment.


EH2R Definitions                                                          EH2R discussion pages; no pictures just ideas





Text and photos by Wayne Davidson. Resident of Resolute Bay, Nunavut Canada.

To contact Wayne


EH2R credits:

Ben Wheeler and Ethan Sollows, video editing of Double Sunset.

Ethan Sollows, April 4 digital pictures

Andrew T. Young's web page "An Introduction to Green Flashes" is essential to understand other refraction effects near the horizon. Dr. Young puts to rest many misconceptions which are still ingrained everywhere.

On his way to the North Pole, Gunther Kletetschka, a physicist, gave me a hand, pictures from his adventure can be found here.

Other related links:

*NEW* Very important sunset sequences can be found at Tom Ruen 's web page. He's a Lake Superior expert on this subject. Some pictures resemble polar pictures, proving that Lake Superior is a cold lake indeed.

Zoltan Neda and other wrote 2 papers on the subject of sun flatness. Great pictures from space show a fantastic resemblance to pictures taken from Resolute Bay.

For a definition of a conventional sunset and sunrise, click here


For more Polar mysteries:

Sir John Franklin was here! : A human tragedy completely ignored and misrepresented.

The Red Star Project: Figuring out how much ozone you have above your roof without any instrument.

EH2r inspired research project:

Stonehenge Then: Many of the sun disk transformations found on this web page ressemble Megalithic structures found throughout the UK, Ireland and Northwestern Europe. Stonehenge Then is a web page designed to recruit more research in horizon observations at Megalith sites. It contains many theories which need field workers to confirm. These theories need to be checked out by hopefully volunteers, or eventually myself.


 
   
     


Global Warming

Visible Global Warming
Refraction
Effects of cold air
Strong Refraction
Horizontal Refraction
Low horizon pictures
Sun pictures
Rectangular sun
Half sun
Red sun
Orange sun
Low Horizon
Rectangular sun
The Line
Novaya Zemlya effect
Ducting of sunlight
The Terminator
Satellite pictures
Visible light
Infrared sun
Sunset Phases
Ellipsoid sun
Arctic twilight
Red Twilight
Orange Twilight
Double sunset
GPS sunset
GPS errors
Sunset times miscalculated
EH2r